Have you ever seen those amazing photos of sourdough breads full of cheeses, herbs, bacon, apples, cinnamon, or cranberries? Those breads have inclusions. Adding inclusions to sourdough bread is a fun way to incorporate different flavors into the bread you know and love.
Adding inclusions to sourdough bread is very simple, once you understand some basic principles. In this post, we will discuss the simplest way to add inclusions to sourdough, including optimal timing, different techniques, and options for shaping, plus a list of over 40 inclusion ideas for you to try!
This list of inclusion ideas was crowdsourced by the Sourdough Mamas over on the Sourdough Mamas Facebook group – thank you all for your ideas and suggestions!
First of all… Is a recipe necessary?
All too often on the Sourdough Mamas Facebook group I see home bakers sharing photos of their inclusion loaves and the comments below say “Recipe please!”
Here’s a little secret: a recipe is not necessary! You can use your tried and true sourdough bread recipe and simply add inclusions to it. It’s really that easy!
How to add inclusions
To add inclusions, you’ll need to weigh out the ingredients and then you will add them either during the third fold, or during the preshape phase, depending on what you’re adding. I write more about this in detail below.
In the baking world, we use bakers percentages to calculate the amount of ingredients to add. As a general rule of thumb, you can start with 20% inclusions. If you find it’s too much, cut it back slightly, and if you find it’s not enough, you can add more!
Bakers percentages can stump some home bakers, so here’s an easy example. Say you want to add cheddar cheese cubes to your bread, and you’re making my Simple Sourdough recipe. It uses 1000g of flour total, and 20% of 1000 is 200, so you would add 200g of cheese.
Prepping your ingredients
Some ingredients you add will need to be soaked, cooked or toasted. This is done to prevent unwanted changes to your hydration and to add better flavor.
Soaking ensures that the inclusion doesn’t rob water from your dough, which would affect its hydration, fermentation and oven spring. Ingredients that require soaking (either overnight or for several hours) include dried fruit such as raisins, cranberries, dried cherries, dried apples, etc. Soaking also decreases the risk of the fruit burning if it’s on the outside of the loaf. TIP: Use a portion of the water from your recipe for soaking to maintain the same hydration in your dough.
Cooking is necessary for some ingredients, like rolled oats, sweet potatoes, bacon and quinoa. Cook as normal, and allow to cool completely before mixing into your dough.
Toasting is a delicious idea for certain nuts and seeds like pecans, almonds, sunflower seeds, sesame seeds, and more. Toasting can be done in the oven or in a skillet on the stove.
When soaking ingredients, use a small portion of the water from your recipe to soak (50g, for example). This way, you won’t need to adjust your hydration.
However, when using “wet” ingredients such as fresh apples, onions, or sweet potatoes, reduce your hydration by 2-5%.
As an example, if you’re making a 75% hydration recipe by using 750g of water with 1000g flour, but including 200g diced apples, you’ll want to reduce your hydration to 70- 73% (700g – 730g of water).
Ingredients to add during third fold
Most sourdough inclusions can be added during the third fold. Things like seeds, nuts and herbs can be safely added at this stage. Simply sprinkle the inclusion on top of the dough, then work them in like you work in your salt. Don’t go crazy, as the inclusion will be dispersed evenly during the fourth fold, preshape and shaping phases.
Ingredients to add during preshape
Some inclusions should be withheld until the preshape stage. This is because we want to keep as much of the inclusion inside the dough as possible, to prevent the ingredients from being on the surface of the dough during baking and therefore protecting them from melting and/or burning.
Ingredients like raisins, cheeses, and orange peel are good examples of inclusions that should be added during the preshape. While preshaping and shaping, do your best to keep the ingredients inside the dough, although it’s okay if a few pierce through the surface. The inclusions you add to your sourdough will be protected inside the dough and away from the direct heat.
All that said, it’s completely up to you when you add your inclusions. Sometimes when adding during the preshape they don’t get dispersed evenly, but the flavor is there and there are no charred bits on the crust. But if you don’t mind some burned raisins on your crust and you’d rather have your ingredients dispersed evenly, by all means, add them during the third fold. You can always make changes based on your results for your next bake!
Adding liquid ingredients
Sometimes you’ll want to add ingredients that are considered a liquid, such as yogurt, purees or beer. In these cases, simply replace up to 20% of the water in the recipe with the liquid inclusion. You cannot add liquid in addition to your regular amounts of water, as this will significantly alter the hydration.
Different shapes for different inclusions (sandwich loaf vs boule)
Depending on your desired outcome, you can make your loaf a different shape. For example, a pesto swirl or cinnamon raisin swirl would work best as a sandwich loaf, rolled up like a jelly roll. Cheddar bacon and apricot pecan, for example, would present better as a boule or batard. Use your creativity when adding inclusions to sourdough!
As you’re baking, keep your final presentation goal in mind and determine which shaping would be best for your inclusion loaves!
And now, here is the list of inclusion inspiration! Have an idea that I missed, or a favorite combo you’ve made? Leave a comment below and I’ll add it to the list so others can try!
Oh, and by the way, if you’re looking for some more help understanding hydration, click here to check out The Beginner’s Guide to Sourdough Hydration.
And don’t forget I have a whole page of resources available to help you in your sourdough journey – click here to find it!
List of inclusion ideas, separated by sweet and savory
- Cherry chocolate
- Sunflower seeds & honey
- Oats & honey
- Cinnamon raisin
- Cinnamon sugar & raisin
- Cinnamon, raisin & apple
- Cardamom, orange peel, cloves & honey
- Pumpkin purée & cranberries
- Maple, pecan & cinnamon
- Apricot & pepitas (pumpkin seeds)
- Apricot pecan
- Raisin walnut
- Blackberries & yogurt
- Cranberry walnut
- White chocolate cranberry pecan
- Mashed sweet potato
- Chopped dates, pecans & cinnamon
- Lemon & white chocolate
- M&M’s (these create a fun rainbow crumb!)
- Cheddar bacon
- Gorgonzola cheese
- Jalapeño cheddar
- Jalapeño, cheese & roasted garlic
- Carmelized onions & gruyere
- Sundried tomato & feta
- Parmesan, truffle & black garlic
- Everything Bagel seasoning
- Colby Jack & pimento
- Kalamata olive & parmesan
- Black & green olive with tomato sauce
- Roasted garlic rosemary
- Green chili cheddar
- Kalamata olive and fire-roasted onions
- Turmeric, chili & poppyseed
- Buttered quinoa
- Roasted garlic parmesan
- Buttered oats
- Caraway seed
- Beer & cheese
- Flamin’ Hot Cheetos and Takis
What did I miss?
Leave me a comment below with new ideas for inclusion inspiration, or let me know which ones you’ve tried and which are your favorite!